The town the boosters left out of the brochure

A rowdy red-light district. Secret tunnels. Scathing newspaper editorials, and a mayor who priced the town’s sins by the week. Wicked Flagstaff is Susan Johnson’s history of the wild early days of northern Arizona’s largest city.

This is the book. The coffee shop is lovely too, but this is the book.

Wicked Flagstaff book cover: a vintage collage over a Sanborn fire insurance map of Flagstaff
Finalist, 2025 Viola Awards · Excellence in StorytellingThe History Press · Wicked seriesArizona Daily Sun · Flagstaff History columnistSourced · from the archives, cited on every page
About the Book

History with the collar unbuttoned

Before the mountain town learned to pose for postcards, it poured, gambled, and paid its fines on a schedule the mayor negotiated personally. Susan Johnson, Flagstaff’s historian of record, spent years in the newspapers and ledgers of the territorial years and came back with the town’s unauthorized biography.

From the publisher: A rowdy red-light district, secret tunnels, and scathing newspaper editorials. Once home to sheep herders and ranchers, the railroad brought a new breed of pioneer to Flagstaff. Entrepreneurs and outlaws alike flocked to the growing town, some finding success and others finding their end at Greenwood Cemetery. When saloons and bawdy houses rebelled against new blue laws, quick-thinking mayor Thomas E. Pollock found a compromise that appeased most locals. Incorrigible characters like Commodore Perry Owens and Ben Doney could be found in town at the Parlor Saloon, while Dutch May Prescott kept the red-light district in the black. Author Susan Johnson uncovers the weird and wicked side of Flagstaff.

Wicked Flagstaff edition details
TitleWicked Flagstaff
AuthorSusan Johnson
PublisherThe History Press
SeriesWicked
PublishedSeptember 16, 2024
Pages128
Paperback ISBN978-1467156394
Paperback price$24.99
E-bookBarnes & Noble NOOK, $10.99
In the Book

Dispatches the Sun would recognize

A Southside Flagstaff corner in storm light, south of the old railroad tracks
South of the tracks

The Red-Light District

The Coconino Sun printed the words in 1916. The town spent a century not repeating them.

Read the story
The October 1901 Sanborn fire insurance map sheet showing saloons labeled along Railroad Avenue in Flagstaff
Railroad Avenue, 1882 to 1917

Saloon Row

By 1886 the saloons outnumbered every other kind of business in town, combined.

Read the story
A downtown Flagstaff alley under a storm-lit sky
Under the downtown blocks

The Tunnels

Every old mountain town swears it has tunnels. Flagstaff actually does. The argument is about what they were for.

Read the story

Plus the blue laws, the lost Greenwood Cemetery, and the rogues who kept the editors in business. All the stories

The Front Page, September 1, 1916

The headline the town never solved

Murder and suicide, or was it double murder. The Coconino Sun set the question in type over the death of Dutch May Prescott, the businesswoman of the restricted district, and a century later the question still stands. The actual front page is on her page here, and the full story is in the book.

Front page of the Coconino Sun, September 1, 1916, with the Dutch May Prescott headline at top left
The Coconino Sun, Friday, September 1, 1916. The Dutch May report leads the page. Library of Congress, Chronicling America, public domain.
Get the Book

Take home the town’s rap sheet

As an Amazon Associate, wickedflagstaff.com earns from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability belong to each retailer.

Susan Johnson, Flagstaff, Arizona author and historian

About the Author

Susan Johnson is a Flagstaff, Arizona author, historian, and paranormal researcher: author of Haunted Flagstaff, Wicked Flagstaff, and Flagstaff’s Walkup Family Murders from The History Press, curator of the weekly Flagstaff History column in the Arizona Daily Sun, and co-founder of Freaky Foot Tours.

Featured on Travel Channel's The Dead Files (2022). Two-time Viola Awards finalist. Flagstaff resident since 1989.

Visit susanjohnson.org